So, the rumor wire has been burning up again about a meal that Manny Ramirez and his agent Scott Boras might or might not have shared with members of the Giants front office.  There are several things we might or might not know about this dinner.  Here are several (though not nearly all).  They might or might not have been discussing a contract.  Boras might or might not have been in town to show Man-Ram that there are people who will overpay for an aging slugger (or at least that have in the past).   They might or might not have gone with the bisque.  However, the meeting also might or might not have happened. 

Where I’m going is that this dinner and its tangibility aren’t at issue here.  In my opinion, there are one of two things that Manny’s going to do this offseason.  1) he’s going to sign with the Giants 2) he won’t.  Beyond that is not important.  There are reasons to sign him.  There are reasons not to.

The reasons to sign Manny Ramirez are rather obvious to anybody who knows his name.  No doubt, it’s agreed upon that he’s among the elite sluggers in the game today.  His entire presence in the lineup will sway how the opposition pitches to a team (not unlike Barry Bonds, once upon a time).  He carries a heavy piece of lumber that can send baseballs into orbit and is an RBI machine.  He puts butts in the seats and probably would deliver a divisional crown to the Bay in 2009.  When he came to LA at the trade deadline last season, they were 54-54 and in second place in the West.  He proceeded to hit .396 with 17 long balls and 53 RBI in 53 games and the Dodgers went on to win the division.  It’s not a reach to give him a lion’s share of the credit for this pennant. 

Now that we have discussed what everybody knows, let’s look at why the Orange and Black might be better suited to look the other way. 

First of all, the outfield isn’t a problem for the Giants.  They already have a log jam with Winn, Rowand, and Lewis starting and Schierholtz biding his time on the bench.  With Manny Ramirez on the team, go ahead and move everybody down one notch. The electric Fred Lewis takes the bench, along with his healthy foot.  Be prepared to see him leave once his contract is up.  Better hope that one won’t turn into the next Giant regret (though I feel it just might).  Schierholtz, with his sweet swing, +.300 MLB average, and no options would probably be shipped out via trade.  I wonder what we’d get for him?  Again, do we really want to see what he does when another team is willing to give him at bats.  What about the veteran Dave Roberts?  I couldn’t see that much changing for him as his contract and speed would probably keep him around for a year.  On defense, Manny Ramirez patrol left field with the grace of a battleship.  Couple this with a less than stellar track record of mental concentration and you get Barry Bonds circa 2007 with a bad case of ADD.  Better hope that Aaron gets some amazing jumps on fly balls in left center.  Also, Manny will probably get +$25 million per.   Rumor has it that Boras is looking for 3-4 years on a deal.   That’s potentially $100 million tied up for four years.  Couple that with the enormous contracts for Rowand and Zito that are also going to be sucking money from the team for the next four seasons.  Want to guess how many quality Giants will say their fair-the-wells to the team in that time?   Lincecum?  Cain?  Sanchez?  These guys are going to need money if the Giants want them to stick around.  Also, Ramirez isn’t exactly young.  At 36, a long term deal will carry him to the doorstep of forty, if not across the threshhold.  Are we to believe that he can still sustain this level of play at that age?  If not, the Giants front office will be mortgaging the future again. 

Again, the Giants will either sign Manny or not.  I just hope that the sayers for the Giants think long and hard before asking him if he wants to stick around for some baked alaska for dessert.